NO, they are not really stupid, they just need to do more research on their agent before they list their home.
Is it me or do you sometimes ask yourself why the "Top Agent" in your neighborhood has so many listings? I wanted to find out so I researched 3 of the top agents in my neighborhood of Mission Hills in San Diego California. When I say "Top Agents", I'm only basing that on the number of listings they have and the number of homes they sell in that neighborhood. Personally I do not consider them as Top Agents.
During the research I found the reason they have so many listings and sellers continue to list with them, THEY LIE TO THEIR SELLERS. If sellers were smarter and did more statistical research on these agents they will find some startling facts.
What lie are the telling? They lie about how much their home is really worth. They inflate the price so they get the listing. Why wouldn't a seller believe an agent whose name is everywhere and they have sold many homes in that neighborhood? Sellers will almost always pick the agent that tells them the highest list price. It's just a fact. What a waste of everyone's time and effort!
If the sellers would ask to see the agent's initial recommended list price versus what the home actually sold for, they would be shocked to see that the price had to be reduced several times in order to get the home sold. I see this as unethical and unfair to those of us that are honest about home values right from the start. I don't like smoke and mirrors, "opinions", and "hunches", etc... I base my pricing on facts, appraisals and CMA's. I know I have lost several listings over the years because I was honest to the sellers about pricing. Some sellers like honesty and can see through the other agent's charade.
One listing presentation I had was for a luxury condo over a million dollars. After we talked about the sour market and current pricing, he looked at me and said, "XYZ agent says he can get 1.3 million for my house and he sells a lot in this building". I turned to him and said, "I can tell you I can get 1.4 million for your place, but it just isn't going to happen." "My pricing is based on facts in the current down market. List your condo with XYZ agent and after your listing period expires, please call me to talk again."
Six months later, he called me back and I'm in process of listing his condo at the correct price even though it lost more value since he waited.
Sellers: PLEASE DO YOUR RESEARCH ON AGENTS BEFORE YOU LIST YOUR HOME! The Top Agent or #1 Agent does not always mean Top Service. Pick the agent that is honest with you and has a proven track record. See more about Todd Armstrong & Associates at www.DwellSanDiego.com